Chapter 9, section 4: Difference between revisions

From Yochai Benkler - Wealth of Networks
Jump to navigation Jump to search
mNo edit summary
No edit summary
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/passi.htm passi] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/mirna/ mirna] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/come-flay/ come flay with me] [http://benevolently.freehostia.com/content/view/chomage/ chomage] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/mutuo-giovani.htm mutuo giovani coppia] [http://benevolently.freehostia.com/content/view/dual-lg/ dual lg] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/aggiornamenti-norton.htm aggiornamenti norton antivirus gratis] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/giochi-lg.htm giochi lg u8120] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/lettore-mp/ lettore mp3 1 gb] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/verbatim-store.htm verbatim store 1] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/al-ristorante.htm al ristorante - dinner party game] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/nossibe/ nossi-be] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/hamlet-hd.htm hamlet hd 250] [http://saline-joy.freehostia.com/web/pmr-midland.htm pmr midland] [http://scaleslea.freewebpage.org/text/directory/budda-bar/ budda bar iii] [http://getm0ney.freewebpage.org/lib/canzoni-casadei/ canzoni casadei] [http://mcwardlo.t35.com/library/html/benq-/ benq 19 pollici] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/hd-ata/ hd ata 100] [http://scaleslea.freewebpage.org/text/directory/rota-nino/ rota nino] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/spagnia-cordoba.htm spagnia cordoba citta] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/je-taime.htm je taime moi no plus] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/smart-nuova/ smart nuova] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/surviving-picasso/ surviving picasso] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/champagne-louis.htm champagne louis roederer 1996] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/informazioni-mutuo/ informazioni mutuo] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/frigorifero-congelatore/ frigorifero congelatore due porte] [http://saline-joy.freehostia.com/web/inni-bersaglieri.htm inni bersaglieri] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/modem-isdn.htm modem isdn 3com] [http://beshennayabelka.freehostia.com/content/view/codici-gta.htm codici gta sant andreas] [http://flheddin.125mb.com/content/view/bsa.htm bsa 2822] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/borsa-per/ borsa per fujifilm] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/scusa/ scusa] [http://getm0ney.freewebpage.org/lib/club/ club 81] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/video-erotico/ video erotico gratis britney spears] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/deja-vu.htm deja vu i can t stop] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/superstiti/ superstiti] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/vacanza-economiche/ vacanza economiche] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/la-paura/ la paura] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/ferrero-rocher.htm ferrero rocher] [http://benevolently.freehostia.com/content/view/dessert-bavarese/ dessert bavarese] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/ibm-hd.htm ibm hd 2 5] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/la-donna.htm la donna perduta] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/karma-killer.htm karma killer] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/fax-network.htm fax network] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/scarpe-onitsuka.htm scarpe onitsuka tiger] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/spagnol/ spagnol] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/hotel-/ hotel 3 stelle barcellona] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/video-del/ video del passato] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/roma-mia.htm roma mia] [http://benevolently.freehostia.com/content/view/philips-magic/ philips magic 3 ppf 531] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/malta-cementizia.htm malta cementizia] [http://mauballe.125mb.com/web/radio-dj/ radio dj rmx] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/tema-sul/ tema sul terrorismo] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/stagno-e.htm stagno e leghe] [http://beshennayabelka.freehostia.com/content/view/sesso-con.htm sesso con francesca] [http://getm0ney.freewebpage.org/lib/sambor/ sambor] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/proposte-ministero.htm proposte ministero dell istruzione 2003] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/placebo-meds.htm placebo meds] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/tori.htm tori] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/memory-streisand.htm memory streisand] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/lettori-mp/ lettori mp3 batteria ricaricabile] [http://getm0ney.freewebpage.org/lib/es-dios/ es dios] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/elisa-toffoli.htm elisa toffoli] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/fluoborite/ fluoborite] [http://flheddin.125mb.com/content/view/le-dolcezze.htm le dolcezze del peccato] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/siamo-fuori.htm siamo fuori dal tunnel] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/houston-limousine/ houston limousine] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/ram-pc/ ram pc133 notebook] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/tyra-banks/ tyra banks] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/lettore-mp/ lettore mp3 usb 1gb radio registratore] [http://getm0ney.freewebpage.org/lib/o-zone/ o zone met dagostea din tei] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/fallo-film/ fallo film di tinto brass] [http://oedi.freehostia.com/text/directory/yara/ yara] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/vector-/ vector 1000 at] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/renault-clio.htm renault clio privilege] [http://oedi.freehostia.com/text/directory/tiziano-ferro/ tiziano ferro ti voglio bene] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/drug-rehab.htm drug rehab] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/rayban-occhiali/ ray-ban occhiali] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/comune-di.htm comune di castelnuovo magra] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/for-a/ for a few dollars more] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/on-an.htm on an evening in roma] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/modem-isdn.htm modem isdn atlantis land] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/atto-daccusa/ atto daccusa] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/lavoro-pistoia.htm lavoro pistoia] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/linguaggio-degli.htm linguaggio degli animali] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/canala.htm canala] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/manuale-powerpoint/ manuale powerpoint] [http://selemku.t35.com/text/directory/labium.htm labium] [http://flheddin.125mb.com/content/view/cdx-cax.htm cdx ca750x] [http://saline-joy.freehostia.com/web/re-collage.htm re collage] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/omm.htm omm] [http://oedi.freehostia.com/text/directory/sabena-airlines/ sabena airlines] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/ojoz/ ojoz] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/chasehq/ chasehq] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/figlio-mio.htm figlio mio] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/dar-unde.htm dar unde esti in full] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/this-love.htm this love and maroon 5] [http://oedi.freehostia.com/text/directory/nike-shox/ nike shox rival] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/cradle-of.htm cradle of filth] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/camera-mont.htm camera mont saint michel] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/sapori-ditalia/ sapori ditalia e dal mondo srl] [http://saline-joy.freehostia.com/web/san-firmin.htm san firmin] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/philips-impianti/ philips impianti hi-fi] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/lg-u.htm lg u8180 cellulari lg] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/tarjetas-y.htm tarjetas y postales] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/testi-system/ testi system of a down] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/fiat-barchetta/ fiat barchetta 1 8] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/scrivere-preventivi/ scrivere preventivi] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/cristo-fra/ cristo fra i muratori] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/toolbox/ toolbox] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/elezioni-sezioni.htm elezioni sezioni messina] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/case-vacanza.htm case vacanza a palermo] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/sciopero-poste/ sciopero poste] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/nel-segno/ nel segno dell amore] [http://beshennayabelka.freehostia.com/content/view/yugiho-per.htm yu-gi-ho per pc] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/bmw-/ bmw 525 tds touring] [http://saline-joy.freehostia.com/web/petera-con.htm petera con] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/tocantins/ tocantins] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/muretto.htm muretto] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/backstreet-boys.htm backstreet boys never gone] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/bubble-jet/ bubble jet ip90] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/un-ultimo.htm un ultimo bacio] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/tv-lcd.htm tv lcd 32 lg] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/love-erotic/ love erotic love] [http://mcwardlo.t35.com/library/html/krishna/ krishna] [http://scaleslea.freewebpage.org/text/directory/she-s/ she s so high by kurt nilsen] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/file-musicali/ file musicali] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/philips-sa/ philips 963sa] [http://benevolently.freehostia.com/content/view/digicom-pci/ digicom pci wireless] [http://scaleslea.freewebpage.org/text/directory/viareggio-casa/ viareggio casa vacanza affitti] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/istria/ istria] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/a-/ a 30 milioni di km dalla terra] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/ops/ ops] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/sexo-con.htm sexo con maduras] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/www-tis.htm www tis] [http://huruple.125mb.com/text/directory/www-yaoo/ www yaoo it] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/caricabatteria-per.htm caricabatteria per videocamera sony] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/noleggio-jeep/ noleggio jeep milano] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/phipps-constantin.htm phipps, constantin john lord ...] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/sex-sexy/ sex sexy] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/mai-piu/ mai piu com te] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/culi-spanati/ culi spanati] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/candyxxx.htm candyxxx] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/clubprive-milano/ clubprive milano] [http://selemku.t35.com/text/directory/intel-server.htm intel server board] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/el-damer/ el damer] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/tompson-twins.htm tompson twins] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/annuncio-lavoro.htm annuncio lavoro liguria] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/tecnoware-alimentatore.htm tecnoware alimentatore] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/una-demo.htm una demo per jedi academy] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/max.htm max70] [http://mauballe.125mb.com/web/toyota-/ toyota  avensis 1.6 16v s.w.] [http://mauballe.125mb.com/web/nun-e/ nun e o vero] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/donna-nuda.htm donna nuda a piacenza] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/telegiros-es.htm telegiros es] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/googli.htm googli] [http://failtoexpress.freehostia.com/html/manovre.htm manovre] [http://mcwardlo.t35.com/library/html/la-coppia/ la coppia trasgressiva] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/scanner-konica.htm scanner konica minolta] [http://mauballe.125mb.com/web/prestito-personali/ prestito personali veloci] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/polio.htm polio] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/storia-di/ storia di instanbul] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/liviu-daniela.htm liviu daniela] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/menil-collection.htm menil collection] [http://kopapguw.homeblock.com/topic/matanzas-provincia/ matanzas (provincia)] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/akai-teramo/ akai teramo] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/spartiti-margherita.htm spartiti margherita] [http://licohwar.homeblock.com/library/html/eracle/ eracle] [http://selemku.t35.com/text/directory/rs-mmc.htm rs mmc dv nokia 6681] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/help-me.htm help me] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/netgear-vpn.htm netgear vpn] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/felpa-eroi.htm felpa eroi] [http://beshennayabelka.freehostia.com/content/view/samsung-televisori.htm samsung televisori] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/sct-keys.htm sct keys] [http://mauballe.125mb.com/web/xerox-phaser/ xerox phaser 3400] [http://getraylo.freeweb7.com/img/styles/il-milionario.htm il milionario canale 5] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/biglietti-nek.htm biglietti nek] [http://lorcaxon.homeblock.com/data/epidinium/ epidinium] [http://selemku.t35.com/text/directory/laurea-in.htm laurea in infermieristica] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/anna-e.htm anna e luca] [http://wainfan.t35.com/view/new/windvd-platinum.htm windvd platinum] [http://greensticky.freehostia.com/library/html/scheda-madre/ scheda madre per amd athlon] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/scompare-una.htm scompare una stella. il mistero della principessa] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/lettori-mp/ lettori mp3 creative muvo] [http://scaleslea.freewebpage.org/text/directory/la-morra/ la morra] [http://grahrens.125mb.com/view/new/surriento/ surriento] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/io-troia/ io troia chatta con me e daniela] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/cazzo-duri/ cazzo duri] [http://flheddin.125mb.com/content/view/hype-.htm hype - the time quest] [http://coarmago.t35.com/content/view/im-loving/ im loving it] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/toner-compatibile.htm toner compatibile kyocera] [http://zoelverd.freeweb7.com/description/lib/pc-spento/ pc spento modem] [http://www.freewebtown.com/prncessprncipe/library/html/microonde-ventilato.htm microonde ventilato combinato] [http://flheddin.125mb.com/content/view/san-marta.htm san marta colombianos] [http://www.freewebtown.com/boogiejames/topic/travelsound.htm travelsound 200] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/comprare-viagra.htm comprare viagra] [http://gawelzba.t35.com/library/html/stuard-little.htm stuard little] [http://www.freewebtown.com/starbriteyellow/resources/articles/hearts-of.htm hearts of iron] [http://boreldar.t35.com/text/directory/miniball.htm miniball] [http://beshennayabelka.freehostia.com/content/view/philips-astaire.htm philips astaire lc6281] <table width="650">
<table width="650">
<tr valign="top">
<tr valign="top">
<td>
<td>

Latest revision as of 06:15, 18 August 2007

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty |Table of Contents | Chapter 9: Summary
Discuss Industrial Organization of HDI-Related Information Industries


Chapter 9 Justice and Development, Section 4:

Industrial Organization of HDI-Related Information Industries

Introduction

Chapter 9

Liberal Theories of Justice and the Networked Information Economy

Chapter 9, section 1

Commons-Based Strategies for Human Welfare and Development

Chapter 9, section 2

Information-Embedded Goods and Tools, Information, and Knowledge

Chapter 9, section 3

* Industrial Organization of HDI-Related Information Industries *

The production of information and knowledge is very different from the production of steel or automobiles. Chapter 2 explains in some detail that information production has always included substantial reliance on nonmarket actors and on nonmarket, nonproprietary settings as core modalities of production. In software, for example, we saw that Mickey and romantic maximizer-type producers, who rely on exclusive rights directly, have accounted for a stable 36-37 percent of market-based revenues for software developers, while the remainder was focused on both supply-side and demand-side improvements in the capacity to offer software services. This number actually overstates the importance of software publishing, because it does not at all count free software development except when it is monetized by an IBM or a Red Hat, leaving tremendous value unaccounted for. A very large portion of the investments and research in any of the information production fields important to human development occur within the category that I have broadly described as "Joe Einstein." These include both those places formally designated for the pursuit of information and knowledge in themselves, like universities, and those that operate in the social sphere, but produce information and knowledge as a more or less central part of their existence-like churches or political parties. Moreover, individuals acting as social beings have played a central role in our information production and exchange system. In order to provide a more sector-specific analysis of how commons-based, as opposed to proprietary, strategies can contribute to development, I offer here a more detailed breakdown specifically of software, scientific publication, agriculture, and biomedical innovation than is provided in chapter 2. Table 9.1 presents a higher-resolution statement of the major actors in these fields, within both the market and the nonmarket sectors, from which we can then begin to analyze the path toward, and the sustainability of, more significant commons-based production of the necessities of human development.

Table 9.1: Map of Players and Roles in Major Relevant Sectors

Actor Sector

Government

Universities, Libraries, etc.

IP-Based Industry

Non-IP-Based Industry

NGOs/Nonprofits

Individuals

Software

Research funding, defense, procurement

Basic research and design; components "incubate" much else

Software publishing (1/3 annual revenue)

Software services, customization (~2/3 annual revenue)

FSF; Apache; W3C; IETF

Free/open-source software

Scientific publication

Research funding

University presses; salaries; promotion and tenure

Elsevier Science; professional associations

Biomed Central

PLoS; ArXiv

Working papers; Web-based self-publishing

Agricultural Biotech

Grants and government labs; NARS

Basic research; tech transfer (24% of patenting activity)

Monsanto, DuPont, Syngenta (~74% of patents)

No obvious equivalent

CAMBIA BIOS CGIAR

Farmers

Biomed/Health

Grants and government labs

Basic research; tech transfer (~50%?)

Big Pharma; Biotech (~50%?)

Generics

OneWorld Health

None

Table 9.1 identifies the relative role of each of the types of main actors in information and knowledge production across the major sectors relevant to contemporary policy debates. It is most important to extract from this table the diversity of business models and roles not only in each industry, but also among industries. This diversity means that different types of actors can have different relative roles: nonprofits as opposed to individuals, universities as opposed to government, or nonproprietary market actors-that is, market actors whose business model is service based or otherwise does not depend on exclusive appropriation of information-as compared to nonmarket actors. The following segments look at each of these sectors more specifically, and describe the ways in which commons-based strategies are already, or could be, used to improve the access to information, knowledge, and the information-embedded goods and tools for human development. However, even a cursory look at the table shows that the current production landscape of software is particularly well suited to having a greater role for commons-based production. For example, exclusive proprietary producers account for only one-third of software-related revenues, even within the market. The remainder is covered by various services and relationships that are compatible with nonproprietary treatment of the software itself. Individuals and nonprofit associations also have played a very large role, and continue to do so, not only in free software development, but in the development of standards as well. As we look at each sector, we see that they differ in their incumbent industrial landscape, and these differences mean that each sector may be more or less amenable to commons-based strategies, and, even if in principle amenable, may present harder or easier transition problems.

Toward Adopting Commons-Based Strategies for Development

Chapter 9, section 5

Commons-Based Research for Food and Medicines

Chapter 9, section 6

Commons-Based Strategies for Development: Conclusion

Chapter 9, section 7

Chapter 9: Notes

Chapter 9: Notes

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty |Table of Contents | Chapter 9: Summary
Discuss Industrial Organization of HDI-Related Information Industries