Chapter 9

From Yochai Benkler - Wealth of Networks
Jump to navigation Jump to search

toyota auto fuoristrada trans cum yamaha rx v550 accessori nikon sq infinity alpha prestito desenzano garda testo furb volante per playstation 2 do you wanna touch me oh yeah ti porto in africa kingston compact flash 1024 jeti la guerra e bluetooth hbh 35 firenze catania biglietti aerei video tette gratis netgear wgr614 802 11g wireless router tecnica decoupage portatile asus m palmari gps cellulari payas chilenas auto noleggio monterotondo machine da corsa diesel infradito volo dakar progdvb 4 43 ballata della societa i ragazzi della motorola black edition sarabande programmi tv di stasera bearshear textbridge pro sax 300 mindrover prestito berlin nada valgo sin tu amor juanes rosaria palm phone gps bt100 appunto filosofia tara patrick video powre rengers matrox x100 asus extreme en6800 pci walkthrough in xenogears noleggio auto lungo termini hit mania dance champion 2004 copertina cd senyor www musica italiana com missa brevis haydn foto terorismo le stagioni dellaquila rl 36 le soulier de satin calci nell pene oki ml-5591 il segreto del medaglione cinema catanzaro dragon ball z. box 01 muvo2 1 5gb biricchina com tuttosesso gay impianti dvd nigger scheda madre celeron fijlkam le ore del giorno e della notte dissipatore socket 7 icone gratis con cambio automatico nokia 6510 numa numa iei mp3 filmes reggiseno in silicone hotel firenze lastminute harman kardon avr235 trasferimento d autorita adattatore video da scart a vga teka bruce boxleitner biggest boob dizionario genovese toner hp c9720a simonini como olvidar linea 77. numbed willage people free download mp3 leccaculo fax canon laser choristes gambe collant denbighshire september moon karpaty spazio di liberta valutiamo tv al plasma e lcd philips www amg it telefonia fissa gabon (estuario) k 550 www ronaldo it peeling lancome cartuccia toner stampante laser brian mcfadden hbh-35 sony ericsson lancia musa diesel platino jeff healey band. live in montreux 1999 full movies mercedes e240 2000 joypad sony per ps2 frac 1 lg mf yo voy allegar entre coralie herpes urin centro sky grosseto nokia 6630 dual mode reconquista (argentina) motori interni x sito giugno 84 tiziano ferro hammam-bou-hadjar ettringite pentax s6 final countdown colonna sonora creative nano zen 1gb yankees alloggio economico braun professional center taraful din clejani opel astra sw benzina navajo joe tito (potenza) testidi canzoni straniere il libanese volo gran bretagna vedove simone jai hub rete 100 tv lcd e decoder terrestre verbatim hi-speed store marillion. marbles on the road www goldrake info af-s nikon 2 8 17-35 driver per scaricare foto motorola v 220 jambalaya dvd liteon amstrad dx3010 brunel college london mutuo prima casa giovani coppi stampante portatile a4 karaoke italiani volibrasile hyundai bologna es 500 armani lei profumo www scuola progettista termotecnico universite stendhal grenoble condizionatori samsung 9000 btu cor du serien scuderia quirinale filmati di lesbiche codici di sblocco motorola a 835 comprare e vendere case g f 4 per elisa beethoven remix cosa regalo poster haring nikon af 35-70mm f 3 3-4 5 d30 canon prefettura domanda di traferimento giacca da cuoco gay movies free canon laser shot lbp-2000 ricetrasmittente ojos de brujos vidio porno kitgum netgear router abiti storici tour cantanti italiani jazz mezzanotte filmati astronomia ga k8ns pro pilote de l appareil photo nforce gagra bruce sprengsteen forno microonde vapore adattatore usb playstation 2 dvx uscita ottica diabolique chamberlain it s tricky bmw x3 usati checker american blue jeans zyxel prestige 2002 monterosso morandi canzoni grotte castelcivita isola d elba alberghi marino marini universal green singole x singoli lombardia volo aereo catania venezia caro zio joe trattorie in lizzano in belvedere donnesexy moto suzuki gsx dili best orario dei voli aerei uomini ciccioni uscita dvi dvd lettori e divx ricerca video aventura lettore samsung toyota land cruiser 2002 star wars galaxies telit bluetooth ristorante tipico portafoglio carabinieri camping jesolo deseos chayanne www shocking com il segreto professionale maxi cosi priori zemanova video porno mldonkey concerto di capodanno a vienna 2001 io vorrei la pelle nera band domani domani rossana casale waves of luf racconti di adulti babies frati domenicani plugin nero 6 www banda max tv opowiesc hannover cose fare q-tec case gps xtrack casse stereo 5 1 liengo logau, friedrich von- hp c3103a sein seiya sonia rolland tps echostar milano mikonos biglietti aerei donne che cercano compagnia sesso video paprika gratis chanapa hd 120 gb maxtor abit fatal1ty fotoannunci erotici jobsonline com mezzanotte damore confetti pelini gay nu sito la freccia nera. vol. 04 polisterolo torino fake cd utensili per fabbro tv color lg popup purger 1 tette da succhiare intel pentium fsb 533 tv color retroproiezione sonic mega collection plus verso i negozi condizionatori fissi argo la planta del albania telecom videotelefono blu ede (nigeria) video nothing else matters dei metallica coppie liguria collant org tonino scardi vestiti da uomo amd fujitsu-siemens computer reggia di caserta blue note a story cd musicali asus pda p505 davide farra ragazze hostes roberto cavalli vestiti automodellismo a scoppio 1 5 tv jvc tastiere per pc ragazza hannover compaq nc8000 tom craft fitness sport canzone carmina sabrina setlur hyper formation soccer catsle ford focus 1.6 16v tabs basso vasco rossi lcd 37 tv philips televisori sito ufficiale giorgia cock robin sicilia pasqua voli low cost amsterdam www trenitali com video clip xxx affitto vacanza calabria convivendo 1 tamron af 18-200mm f 3 5-6 3 xr parabrezza bicicletta nessuna demo per unreal ii macchina caffe viceversa toner epson c900 km0 bmw x5 diesel auto km 0 la ragazza dal lecca lecca wrangler jeep sostakovic gay villosi gigi dag isola di ischia www porno film com il potere di satana - le streghe della luna nera www adrianocelentano com hosting italia www coithienthai org vin diesel video che cosse l amore olivetti pg404 ati radeon 7000 64 mercatini antiquariato lean back terror squad gun s roses knocking on heaven s door le finaliste di veline arcana manager fifa bd 292 ai notai fiuggi cartografia ministeriale www diccionario com amstrad divx dx 3010 franceso di gregori ieft dragostea testo nasro origamo pietre naturali treviso lost s02 league calendario gq grow cube ver 3 usb 4 giga gta celosa hirai ken hitomi deen feat funky g danza immagini sistem of a dwon uomini giovani www photo hard eva henger com quieren que les cante diesel bianco cotone r y ford focus coupe www libero porno it vegas pull up global geografia fondi marini caboblanco creative muvo tx se 512 depeche mode - songs of faith and macchina per pasta sfoglia tablature chitarra metallica one lezioni video salsa yamaha sintoamplificatore casse analisi ambiente tv lcd 14 villagio vacanze puglia range rover 2.5 donne mature sexi mind body and soul casio slim telecom ellisse voice swyx solution partner videogioco on line nikon coolpix 7900 gf 6800 le sling along side idaho cose fare calendario barbara d urso recorder hard disk divx comune di fara gera d adda kate playground zr colin mc rae rally 2005 pure poison dior archivio meteo 2 giugno 2004 lacie firewire mobile gente della notte olympus 730 shox nike 46 anelli oro signore viaggio damore uno scandalo a parigi zombi erik pancho y la sonora colorada will youg nike air resolve td sony dsc-st80 trans chat pennini asus dancing in the moodlight fax e stampante funkytown calendario panorama sito ufficiale yu gi ho online giochi la sagra di giarabub temi nokia gratis usercenter cox net blu eyes mortasare olimpus c 8080 radio stations sor- sabatini nuda maultaschen giochi puzzle da ricomporre amstrad dx3035 elmundodeportivo alabastrite lowepro trekker aw baby h mere naseeb mp3 science gothic ii pascuale tutto su aerei futura concessionarie per la campagnia crack clone dvd ridere per ridere toshiba rd-xs34 la biografia cartuccia rigenerate rap west coast progesoft batteria zen micro canzoni zecchino d oro 1973 ventola raffreddamento hd alba parietti film dvd carta trezzo sull adda peter cetera hks 3 un osito de peluche irdeto art hispachat siemens amilo d1845 ram 512 paola borboni pipeline foto anya lahiri applicatore etichetta party summer 2004 incontro al central park windows professional oem sex amimale smile chaplin ghostngoblins chevrolet corvette teen video at 325 alu guzzi moto modellismo salin giancarlo altoparlanti creative subwoofer gathering como fue la musica partir de la conquis incisa filosofia del diritto palermo lessbo foggy come dream venditori tecnici (regione piemonte - torino provincia) figc firenze daddo baci lesbo tra vip ministerointerni eleonora di miele che sos e la vitiligine geldrop nintendo donkey konga bongo popeye. vol. 13 escortforum cir i culi piu belli sora fotocamera digitale reflex adsl 4 porte ethernet nuova maa assicurazioni lesbiche pelose antares - srl zylom discoteca los angeles 2 7 2004 zyxel 650h s coopia trasmettitore fm da mp3 big city life dildo xxx videochat con carta sessso gratis alexandra strip dragon ball z assorbente vicenza cartina geografica california analog switches treni a vapore hp compaq nx 8220 vivo di renato zero asus car kit bmw z8 asus p4p800-se manifestazione a udine ricerca sul calcetto binocolo impermeabile every other time lfo albergo a venezia classifica campionato serie b risultati calcistici km0 mini cabrio auto km 0 guns n roses mp3 core core equazioni fratte il giardino dei semplici polti 1000 immagini rigano il malessere giovanile e la scuola se l amore ha scelto noi o thou that tellest good tidings to zion pamela anderson gq omologazioni impianti autotrazione sony dsc w12 giovanni storti www receita federal com br contribuinte fujifilm mv 1 ksyrium elite milva successi i sony 1gb hotel a gubbio sale cinematografiche batteria nikon 4800 verbatim mcc scooter usato piaggio hp nx6125 sempron xbox dvd people get ready 99 pthc polo tdi phonocar condensatore ufficio tivoli earth song dammi tre parole le fate dei boschi siboney ultima calcio mercato punto 1 3 multijet to racconti di clisteri casalinghe quarantenni che si scopano il siemens tx200 z 517 trame film di germi autolinee per tropea da cosenza spiderman soundtrack puma calzature sport donna kit cinema adattatore gamepad gay naked ariete 2790 tonkin casse creative i trigue 3400 2 1 renault it if i could fly perino giuseppe him resurrection router adsl zyxel alfa romeo gtv milano portatili cdc columbus hp 9800 ferro caldaia nostop vapor far cry sdk sex anal vecchia fattoria ghandi dvd marrakech express hotel maurizius sony sdm hs75pb collettori auto chat gay gratuita roma tema svolto razzismo rpl sas decollete 3d intervista nel matrix philips 17 monitor mp3 dance gratis knocking on haven s door telecamere videosorveglianza allarmi sometime di britney spears router access point adsl clef de tps note di statistica descrittiva musica di t innamorerai brocken traduzione in italiano aerografo per verniciatura surfin aaron carter vitamina leche caliente fiat stilo 140 cv y sigue segretaria tettona missa ad majorem dei gloriam aveva gli occhi neri accordi breack cordless siemens s44 ladro del supermercato korg o1 pietre dure ingrosso ray ban balorama rebecca roos tras- uy tour biagio antonacci ho ice inti hp 3970 scopa picture very very sexy in ogni momento california dei phantom vivavoce nokia-6110 manifesto ringraziamenti cd di blue boac murolo mia martini pantalone con tasconi incontri a jesi videocamere foto www rai it lan pcmcia lo chef a casa sei anima gianna nannini omaggio floreali land rover discovery 2 5 td panasonic sa xr30 video teen no nude lcd samsung le32r51 f-zero canon ef 70-200mm f 2 8l usm comprare libri on line godavari, west- natascha sms-it sex sites canoa olimpica albergo centro storico roma ml to sensual girls 1 - wallpaper - 640 bajar videos musicales de yandel lagosto di cecchi gori - 2 furioso polka tribinale bari sanyo batterie home theatre bose giochi da azione la tasha marzolla burn it blue limpopo audi a3 sportback ambiente siemens stylistic telefonino videosorveglianza nardi muzica audio gratis canzoni mp3 di fabri fibra emerson lake palmer ragazzo bern janet barboza formula vibration feedback wheel uccello murano brigata meccanizzata sassari muscle gay il pozzo e pendolo militari kamasudra www assistente tecnico it exe exe video scandalo gratis sl 55 amg jfive modern time trapani milano biglietti aerei villaggio in croazia argo 16 valentino ken russell calogero yalla mar mediterraneo revolving festa arma carabiniere nikon 35-70 michaela www mov it cd alan parsons don ameche tomtom holder - ipaq series aprire attivita franchising foto mar rosso videos gratis break-up figa rotta funcard 6 1 file lel calzaturifici pistoia ricambio usati auto noleggio rozzano madadayo www codec singoli in gruppo giro d italia 2001 masterizzatore esterno masterizzatori cd dlaczzego foto gabry ponte natalia cruze n200 512mb technisat skystar usb midi file moondance elio germano kurve blue curtian falls el telescopio schede madri epox conto terzi figa celebrita ludwig van beethoven. violin concerto intel p4 830 ferrari modena bilancio fiat ford fiesta newport 1.3 registrzione docg ryan oneal audi nuoro creazioni roberto porto di bari iodio messaggi comici elezioni italia jeans diesel kuratt www lolloscan com lope, manuel de- matura tit ignacio larranaga deh-p70bt bluetooth internet www mykindaplace com reptilia strokes indirizzi dentisti prezioso midi olidata monitor 19 tft phantom of the opera song palmari mio accessori emmen (paesi bassi) david draiman forsaken www incredibili it kings of confidence web free voyager 1994 justin timberlake. live from london s w a t libri scaricare gratis il trovatore it www immigration immagini dei campeggi calabresi cono per basso pentium m 735 moto buell ramzy bedia centro addestramento cinofilo a padova lavoro al bar scarlet diva trailer h500 motorola olivetti d-copia 16 behringer xm8500 marmitte cross ekaf parafrasi cavalcanti csi perugia vado a riprendermi il gatto nick berg filmato qilian shan zuccero mana arredamento negozi abbigliamento dwie morgi verbatim sd guerra fra pianeti daddy yankee don omar tego cal maray carey fiorello cd www mediasat it

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty |Table of Contents | Chapter 9: Summary
Discuss Justice and Development: Introduction


Chapter 9: Justice and Development

Introduction

How will the emergence of a substantial sector of nonmarket, commons-based production in the information economy affect questions of distribution and human well-being? The pessimistic answer is, very little. Hunger, disease, and deeply rooted racial, ethnic, or class stratification will not be solved by a more decentralized, nonproprietary information production system. Without clean water, basic literacy, moderately well-functioning governments, and universal practical adoption of the commitment to treat all human beings as fundamentally deserving of equal regard, the fancy Internet-based society will have little effect on the billions living in poverty or deprivation, either in the rich world, or, more urgently and deeply, in poor and middle-income economies. There is enough truth in this pessimistic answer to require us to tread lightly in embracing the belief that the shift to a networked information economy can indeed have meaningful effects in the domain of justice and human development.

Despite the caution required in overstating the role that the networked information economy can play in solving issues of justice, it is important to recognize that information, knowledge, and culture are core inputs into human welfare. Agricultural knowledge and biological innovation are central to food security. Medical innovation and access to its fruits are central to living a long and healthy life. Literacy and education are central to individual growth, to democratic self-governance, and to economic capabilities. Economic growth itself is critically dependent on innovation and information. For all these reasons, information policy has become a critical element of development policy and the question of how societies attain and distribute human welfare and well-being. Access to knowledge has become central to human development. The emergence of the networked information economy offers definable opportunities for improvement in the normative domain of justice, as it does for freedom, by comparison to what was achievable in the industrial information economy.

We can analyze the implications of the emergence of the networked information economy for justice or equality within two quite different frames. The first is liberal, and concerned primarily with some form of equality of opportunity. The second is social-democratic, or development oriented, and focused on universal provision of a substantial set of elements of human well-being. The availability of information from nonmarket sources and the range of opportunities to act within a nonproprietary production environment improve distribution in both these frameworks, but in different ways. Despite the differences, within both frameworks the effect crystallizes into one of access-access to opportunities for one's own action, and access to the outputs and inputs of the information economy. The industrial economy creates cost barriers and transactional-institutional barriers to both these domains. The networked information economy reduces both types of barriers, or creates alternative paths around them. It thereby equalizes, to some extent, both the opportunities to participate as an economic actor and the practical capacity to partake of the fruits of the increasingly information-based global economy.

The opportunities that the network information economy offers, however, often run counter to the central policy drive of both the United States and the European Union in the international trade and intellectual property systems. These two major powers have systematically pushed for ever-stronger proprietary protection and increasing reliance on strong patents, copyrights, and similar exclusive rights as the core information policy for growth and development. Chapter 2 explains why such a policy is suspect from a purely economic perspective concerned with optimizing innovation. A system that relies too heavily on proprietary approaches to information production is not, however, merely inefficient. It is unjust. Proprietary rights are designed to elicit signals of people's willingness and ability to pay. In the presence of extreme distribution differences like those that characterize the global economy, the market is a poor measure of comparative welfare. A system that signals what innovations are most desirable and rations access to these innovations based on ability, as well as willingness, to pay, overrepresents welfare gains of the wealthy and underrepresents welfare gains of the poor. Twenty thousand American teenagers can simply afford, and will be willing to pay, much more for acne medication than the more than a million Africans who die of malaria every year can afford to pay for a vaccine. A system that relies too heavily on proprietary models for managing information production and exchange is unjust because it is geared toward serving small welfare increases for people who can pay a lot for incremental improvements in welfare, and against providing large welfare increases for people who cannot pay for what they need.

Liberal Theories of Justice and the Networked Information Economy

Chapter 9, section 1

Commons-Based Strategies for Human Welfare and Development

Chapter 9, section 2

Information-Embedded Goods and Tools, Information, and Knowledge

Chapter 9, section 3

Industrial Organization of HDI-Related Information Industries

Chapter 9, section 4

Toward Adopting Commons-Based Strategies for Development

Chapter 9, section 5

Commons-Based Research for Food and Medicines

Chapter 9, section 6

Commons-Based Strategies for Development: Conclusion

Chapter 9, section 7

John Stuart Mill, On Liberty |Table of Contents | Chapter 9: Summary
Discuss Justice and Development: Introduction