9. Justice and Development

From Yochai Benkler - Wealth of Networks
Jump to navigation Jump to search

guzzi moto modellismo hit mania dance summer 2004 giacche 2004 eva folk tesina gia svolte donne a pagamento concessionari mbk scooter provincia mi thiel cs2 i don t wanna know di mario winans tv sony klv 20 dubcova cubi puzzle inglesina liberty gruppo musicale dei blue brava casa me libere free skip nasty chat indesit silver r24s treo palmone quotazioni auto storiche calde notti destate www incantesimo rai it chiedere prestito online modifica honda bf 40 psicologia di internet pinball pc federico salvatore testi vigili urbani aquila beep audio key mp3 packard bell oye mi amor non solo ciclismo libri caratteristiche della libia r 1200 gs erotic maniac jennilopez clases de canto tafi www porta portese it vietsex foto di adam levine hard disk mobile freecom i classici di revolution potrebbero essere aggiornati amanti felici montalbano dvd cofanetto concorsi a s l citta di milano toner laserjet 2200 schede madri 462 soweto string quartet fimati erotici citofono bmw 540i touring elodie michal b u g mafia gore tex navigatore bluethoot hp inkjet 6620 gioco sparatoria nikeid com europe princess diana crash fotografie calendari lesbo hotel san marco parma fc voli low cost alghero venezia decoder falcon ci 6600 numeri telefonici di myami rivenditori caschi da moto la croce gloriosa guida alla muscolazione villa pini foto montagna vogliosa di cazzo volo los angeles azardo immagine drago beach girl navigatori gps palmari schlick, arnolt carnet di ballo himno nacional del per kancelarya huntington park televisore lcd 15 e radio stampanti con scanner lexmark sony wireless home theatre estetista corsi game boy advance sp artic blue la guerra dei gavettoni sentiero solitario s paulu adidas zip sony dcr-hc 30e regali idea regalo scacchiere ci vuole un attimo aleandro baldi mappa berlino video de decapitation de paul jonson plasma panasonic 37 tetra- bagutti midi www bahia it laser hp stampante pelletterie in firenze hard disk con lettori di schede video esecuzioni in irak www ea games it telefono rovigo vermilion nokia 3510 telefonino la torre del mangia salt un gioco di sparatutto u.d.o. thundervision never stop lumix 8 maracaibo colombo hp- officejet 7210 nuovi zombies sui nostri schermi seca residenza teo mammuccari cd quartetto pazzo stafania orlando testo my heart will go on ventose bagno archivio estrazione lotto tastiera e mouse per apple maria rosa mare vacanza puglia aereoporto linate aesop banner maker designer scaffale designjet 130 nr rich jeans microsoft windows xp media ipod speaker jbl pci-express - ati sapphire radeon x550 immagini diddl desktop www alberghi mestre sborrate con noi linch senza cravata foto carolina total request live mtv il teschio di londra inuyasha e kagome barche in vetroresina cineriz li jon lavastoviglie scomparsa totale sintoamplificatori lettore dvd jamie pressley publicinvasion semolei la fiamma the doctor rex congelatore ci100fb attrezzatura bar ariete toast mezzora dei zero assoluto vendita quadri altoparlanti ipod lansing noi siamo angeli. vol. 02 softice carmen di pietro video fotocamera per hp ipaq biebl, konstantin halmahera porno film il primo cerchio interfaccia pioneer sakmann, bert il pilota del danubio video free gay heart rata monitor pc siemens deskstar t7k250 nomi di cantanti di cartoons dawnload gioco gratis fortuna clip stato patrimoniale kojiro shout honda gold wing zubair sigla di contro campo frajese ricetrasmettitori alan 777 pescare egitto sharm vacanze www provveditorato studi milano anitra bengali elion dizionario della lingua italiana videocamere digitali canon mvx300 wallpaper gratis congresso kyoto 1997 motori stradali charlotte church. dream a dream Table Of Contents


Summary of the chapter

Professor Benkler specifically contemplates the influence of burgeoning non-market common-based production on the issue of justice and development.

Current dominant market-based production lays its foundation on the economic incentive for production and innovation. It relies on the proprietary protection to create exclusive rights as the core policy for growth and development. However, the system has negative effects on the issue of distribution.

Starting from an overview of the theories of justice associated with liberalism. Professor Benkler argues that as long as we admit that poverty or plight could come from situations (bad luck) and not just a result of personal choices (responsitivity). Certain arrangements of wealth redistribution may be necessary to promote justice.

The issue of unequal distribution of wealth creates gross injustice at the international level. It is obvious for the distribution of food and medicine. Adolescents in America buy many kinds of medicines for acne and can afford it, while thousands of children in Africa and Asia die from diseases that can be cured easily by modern medicine but they cannot afford it. Furthermore, the market-based economy creates incentives for innovation to serve the needs of the rich and ignore the needs of the poor. More researches are conducted to cure minor diseases in the wealthy North rather than considering life-threatening deceases in the poor South.

Professor Benkler contends that accusing private corporations is not only useless but also unfair. Directors in such companies have fiduciary duties to maximise their shareholders’ wealth. The injustice result is the aggregate effect of the market-based production economy.

The common-based production economy provides an alternative to the market-based economy to generate innovations and productions that can satisfy the needs of the poor. Professor Benkler analyses different types of goods and provides an account about how common-based information economy may help to ameliorate the growing gap. For example, the MIT Open Courseware initiative provides students and teachers around the world with free and easy access to the knowledge generated by one of the best institutions in the world.

Food and medicine are the most urgent needs of developing countries. Current innovations in the agricultural biotechnological industry are increasingly relying on the private sector. Their innovations are protected by patent rights which prevents poor countries from using them as unaffordable. The common-based production model could also provide promising results in reversing such a trend. Efforts like PIPRA (Public Intellectual Property for Agriculture) or BIOS (Biotechnology Innovation for an Open Society) serve as examples for non-profit-driven research and overcome patent barriers created by the market-based economy. In the area of medical science, efforts have been made to increase research regarding developing countries health issues. A proposed experiment at the University of Indiana-Purdue University at Indianapolis provides simple, low-cost kits for training students in chemical synthesis to conduct experiments with a view to treating diseases in the developing countries. With enough redundancy across classrooms and institutions around the world, useful drugs might be invented to help developing countries.

The common-based production economy was made possible through the effect of the cheap communication framework provided by the Internet. Professor Benkler shows how the rich North could generate information and innovations for the poor South. However, what Internet could achieve is not only allowing more researchers to help developing countries, but also have an empowerment effect on the developing world. Professor Benkler mentioned that the insufficiency of food and drugs in many third-world nations is not only caused by the high prices but also caused by malfunctioning transportation and distribution. Bad governance has been identified by the World Bank as the major reason that cripples developing countries from development. Systemic corruption will jeopardize any efforts to help local people in these countries. The most vivid example is the GlaxoSmithKline case. In the year of 2002, Glaxo provided cheaper drugs treating patients with HIV in African countries but these drugs were resold at higher price in Europe by corrupted government officials in the African countries. Though the use of internet, information about local governments operations could be more easily observed by the people. For developing countries that have passed the threshold of having access to internet, such as China or India, the effect of empowerment of the people can be observed even under censorship. For other countries that cannot afford the basic infrastructure of having access to the Internet, the effort to create cheaper infrastructure has already been launched. MIT cooperated with a Taiwanese computer manufacturing company, Quanta, to manufacture cheap computers in order to allow “One Laptop Per Child” in developing countries. Only through empowerment of the people in the developing countries, can developing world really come up with their own way to rescue themselves out from the vicious circle. Professor Benkler raises an important question in this chapter. He asks: “ What has Wikipedia got to do with the 49 percent of the population of Congo that lacks sustainable access to improve water resources?” He answers this question by how the new common-based production information economy in the developed countries can produce more goods and innovations to benefit the developing countries. The common-based economy could also come up with programs such as the MIT-Quanta “One Child Per Laptop” initiative to allow people in the developing countries to have cheaper and easier access to knowledge and find out their own way of development. The current infrastructure of the internet, dominated by companies such as Microsoft and Intel, is itself a problem. Endless coerced upgrading practices protected by the Intellectual Property system and formidable network externality make the infrastructure of internet towards an unaffordable direction for the poor South. More efforts should be made to allow cheaper alternatives to be generated by the common-based information economy.


Liberal Theories of Justice and the Networked Information Economy

Benkler sorts liberal theories of justice into buckets, based on how they explain the sources of inequality. The three primary explanations are (1) luck, (2) responsibility, and (3) structure. The main thesis of this section is that the networked information economy offers concrete improvements over proprietary market economies along all three lines of liberal theories of justice.


Luck refers to “reasons for the poverty of an individual that are beyond his or her control, and that are part of that individual’s lot in life unaffected by his or her choices or actions.”

John Rawls - A Theory of Justice (amazon), or A Theory of Justice (wikipedia)

Benkler's use of Rawls' work is rooted in three of Rawls' principles.

  • First, Rawls starts from the foundational assumption that the poorest people are in their condition only because of dumb luck.
  • Second, Rawls is famous for his "difference principal," which proposes that society should provide those worst off with the benefits of redistribution or growth of wealth.
  • Third, Rawls uses a thought experiment called the "Veil of Innocence" to propose a mechanism to maximize justice for all members of society. Rawls proposes that principles of justice would be maximized when established from behind a theoretical “veil of innocence,” where “no one knows his place in society, his class position or social status, nor does anyone know his fortune in the distribution of natural assets and abilities, his intelligence, strength, and the like. I shall even assume that the parties do not know their conceptions of the good or their special psychological propensities.” Only then would parties unselfishly maximize the probability that no member of society would experience poverty or injustice.

Benkler's observations:

  • If we were to rationally distribute our resources behind the "veil of innocence," we would make rationale decisions, but would not distribute wealth exactly equally. We will trade overall productivity to help the worst cases, but we won't, and shouldn't, make the huge sacrifices in productivity necessary for a totally equal system.


Responsibility refers to “causes for the poverty of an individual that can be traced back to his or her actions or choices.

Robert Nozick - [http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0465097200/qid=1146501412/sr=2-1/ref=pd_bbs_b_2_1/104-2322222-6539953?v=glance