6. Political Freedom Part 1: The Trouble with Mass Media

From Yochai Benkler - Wealth of Networks
Jump to navigation Jump to search

auto peugeot 206 dvd 3010 nadja farrag busi maria luisa foto fucini, renato il signore degli anelli - il ritorno del finanziamento treviglio cancion de la burbuja figlie maradona cinque milioni di playstation 2 in inghilterra provincia di cagliari catena umana bebir la fame nel mondo accusync lcd92vm panasonic 10 videocamere destiny child lose my breath non solo hollywood paris (texas) juegos de game boy micro hifi majestic kellis trick riang puma calcetto jil stargate sg-1 si presenta in video giustino (trento) rhe item com free download mp3 console nintendo game boy advance bass tabs litfiba gazzettadel sud sms da pc outlet village franciacorta amadio srl webcam perso foto nek www cienciano com www cumbia com nikon d 70s kit kukulska hit me hart i will fly thomas funerale a los angeles trullo ostuni www forecasts gr acquistare diamanti legal forms scienze motorie ennio moricone mission cienciano porta hi-fi ddr dual alley cat benny benassi vs klubbheads satisfaction carmen e mauro www i roteo it sesso con gli animali olympus 5000 www miracoli it frank adenture 2 la canzone dell acqua codec dvx osanna mid ragazza chiavari le piccanti confessioni di una giovane studentessa apple mini i-pod intel p4 530 carolina e tommaso la favola continua commandments passeggini quinny centoxcento net loredana berte nuovo album trattori usato umbria uno sconosciuto alla mia porta paso amplificatore electrolux oxygen hotel a bratislava isoladelba assault lexus connessioni errore 734 netgear bundle wall-plugged wireless try nelli furtado the way you make me feel michael jackson barbara bush nuda oxyturbo srl rack case 19 barbara la marr i m so sexy scienze giuridiche acquista nokia 6630 pioneer p80mp nikon 7900 h 70 micro atx athlon 64 e-home wonder gps nautico accompagnatrici online fleetwood mac. destiny rules lauraandresan konica minolta a2 michael jackson concerto budapest spartiti per chitarra pdf rsn possibili ritardi per gran turismo 4 in europa tomtomgo gps tomtom e accessori thicke when i get you alone scheda madre gigabyte 64 umts nokia 6630 mirabilandia it www mobylines it egitto intrattenimento schede audio usb the simsville - video esame di guida khorramshahr axim palmare consultazioni provinciali 2004 hp q6001a giochi da botte decibel definizione mosca non crede alle lacrime adidas adi speed www arab1000 com campeggio gallipoli claudio baglioni ale oo lcd monitor 20 wide mature treviso duda biglietto compleanno d augurio supereva com hardware televisioni mivar code numerique taquilla itinerario livorno londra dentro monitor lcd 15 compaq windows media center edition 2005 face la mer sambenedettese calcio moe il natale di poirot agatha christie eccezzziunale veramente oroscopi di coppia pneomatici moto sounds dvd light scribe bmw x3 km0 mezz ora zeo assoluto stelvio seal love s divine solimano ii suoneria polifonica cellulare sedia impilabili veriton 7700gx sisal adult web hosting xs drive 2 ibm r50e centrino destructors mixer pro tps code xsat 410 nike lite leather nic unic dvd divx portatili musique gratuite le anime veloci fotos de chiquillas desnudas fighting evolution epson emp s1h svga canon d 300 hp viamichelin grigliata monitor 17 casse pedicure retarder gigabyte k8nxp-sli io me ne andrei un angel no es cuffie sennheiser px 100 gay gallerie di sesso gratuite kyosho fw-05t assorbente treviso cerimonia unna normative consegna materiali dichiarazione ica libreria cristallo etrex venture most wanted - ricercato afyon - oppio chattare con la prov di cagliari mouse infrarosso enanitos verde internet wind demetrio albertini legatorie milano occhiali dior d nikon capture 3 Table Of Contents


Summary of the chapter


The concept of public sphere can be narrowed down to the “set of practices members of a society use to communicate about matters they understand to be of public concern and that potentially require collective action or recognition” (177). This chapter argues that as a way to structure these practices, mass media has weaknesses: it offers no return loop from the edges to the core (feedback is local or one-to-one) and relies on a passive consumer culture. The Internet and the emerging networked information economy provide a better public platform.

Communication in the public sphere is structured not only by technical infrastructures, but also by modes of organization, economic models of production, culture (literacy, social egalitarianism, etc.), and institutions (legal frameworks, subsidies). For example, equivalent technical platforms were available in France, the UK and the US a century ago and later in the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany. Yet active public spheres did not always emerge (although repressive regimes may have one, if political opinions spread through networks) and when they did they varied in relative elitism (UK) or populism (US). There was also variation in who supported production hubs, whether it be the state (most countries), advertisers (CNN), combinations of both (BBC, CBC), civil society (party presses in Europe) or nonprofits (the Consumer Report in the US). These distinctions are helpful because they remind us that Internet access will not determine the new public sphere; human capital and agency as well as collective choices based on culture and institutions may well matter more.

Design Characteristics of A Communications Platform For a Liberal Public Platform or a Liberal Public Sphere

There are several basic characteristics of the public sphere necessary, in a wide range of democracies, to communicate private opinion and convert it into public, political opinion and later into formal state action:

  • Universal intake. This does not mean that every voice is heard and every concern debated and answered, but rather that in principle anyone's situation can be considered when someone believes it requires public attention.
  • Filtering for potential political relevance. This is necessary so that the public can focus on important issues.
  • Filtering for accreditation. This ensures that the information communicated is credible.
  • Synthesis of public opinion. What counts as public opinion varies between and among deliberative conceptions and pluralist conceptions of democracy, but some combination of clusters of individual opinion is essential.
  • Independence from governmental control. Though the government can participate in explicit conversations and the administration receives instructions from their output, neither controls the platform itself.

The first and last requirements are the most controversial, for they raise the issue of so-called authoritarian public spheres. Benkler begins this section with Harbermas' descriptive definition of a public sphere and asserts that it can be liberal or authoritarian. The difference is that people in the idealized Athenian agora or New England town halls express, listen to and evaluate proposals, facts, concerns and opinions with complete freedom, while in authoritarian regimes “communications are regimented and controlled by the government in order to achieve acquiescence and to mobilize support” (181). In both cases at least some private opinions are communicated and converted into state action.

Yet when Benkler sets out to define the above criteria (182), he only has "a wide range of conceptions of democracy" in mind, not authoritarian regimes where the public sphere may be partially independent and theoretically universal. It thus seems to make little sense to speak of authoritarian public spheres; in fact, regimes that allow a political, public opinion to form and to influence or “convert into” state action are usually considered democratic. But the extent to which they do so is difficult to assess, since sophisticated executives in any regime both listen to public opinion and retain their own agenda (See Case Studies below).

The Emergence of the Commercial Mass-Media Platform for the Public Sphere

In seventeenth-century Britain, the dissolution of the Stationers' Monopoly was met by libel prosecutions, high stamp taxes, bribery and the type of government acquisition and censorship typical in pre-revolutionary France. Overall the press was compliant and distributed to elite audiences. In contrast, eighteenth- and nineteenth-century America saw the rise of media competition and weekly circulation as a result of low regulation, high literacy, and prosperity. Local, small-circulation newspapers, however, came under pressure from economies of scale produced by technological innovations (mechanical presses, telegraphs, railways, etc.) and barriers to entry arose: “James Gordon Bennett founded The Herald in 1835 with an investment... equal to a little more than $10,400 in 2005 dollars”; by 1840 the necessary investment was $106,000–$212,000 and by 1850, $2.38 million in 2005 terms (188).

The invention of radio was the only potential inflection point before the Internet. Many countries did adopt a BBC-inspired hybrid model (Canada, Australia, Israel, India) insulated from market and government pressures. But in the US, a combination of technology, business practices and regulatory decisions replicated and expanded the commercial mass-media model, which would also be a template for television. Herbert Hoover did seek some form of nationalization of radio in the name of public interest, but from 1922 on his policies would “systematically benefit large commercial broadcasters” (e.g. the RCA-GE-AT