Mirror As You Link - Revision history

MirrorAsYouLink: Changed all references to WTP to MAYL, keeping things consistent

2011-11-13T20:43:17Z

Changed all references to WTP to MAYL, keeping things consistent

MirrorAsYouLink: /* The Idea */

2011-10-15T22:24:47Z

The Idea

← Older revision		Revision as of 22:24, 15 October 2011
Line 18:		Line 18:
	In practice, WTP will work like this: An independent reporter links to the website of a political activist from Iran, and uses WTP to ensure that if the activist's website goes down, the content that she linked to will still be available. While the activist's website is still up and available, the mirrored is not apparent or intrusive. Later, however, the activist's website goes down as a result of a DDOS attack. Without WTP, the reporter would no longer be able to provide access to the activists content. However, with WTP implemented, when a reader clicks on the link to the activist's website and finds that it is down, the reader will automatically be redirected to the mirror of the website, rendering the DDOS attack ineffective in silencing the activist.		In practice, WTP will work like this: An independent reporter links to the website of a political activist from Iran, and uses WTP to ensure that if the activist's website goes down, the content that she linked to will still be available. While the activist's website is still up and available, the mirrored is not apparent or intrusive. Later, however, the activist's website goes down as a result of a DDOS attack. Without WTP, the reporter would no longer be able to provide access to the activists content. However, with WTP implemented, when a reader clicks on the link to the activist's website and finds that it is down, the reader will automatically be redirected to the mirror of the website, rendering the DDOS attack ineffective in silencing the activist.

	Such an implementation would provide a means for those running servers to preserve online content, but would not provide a means for the bulk of netizens to do so. As such, we also envision creating a tool, much like [http://tinyurl.com/ TinyURL] or [http://www.webcitation.org/ WebCite], that would allow users without websites of their own to create mirrors of content. This service could be marketed as an online source preservation tool. Although the initial implementation would be centralized, the end goal is to create an Apache extension that could be adopted by those who would like to offer their own similar service.		Such an implementation would provide a means for those running servers to preserve online content, but would not provide a means for the bulk of netizens to do so. As such, we also envision creating a tool, much like [http://tinyurl.com/ TinyURL] or [http://www.webcitation.org/ WebCite], that would allow users without websites of their own to create mirrors of content. This service could be marketed as an online source preservation tool. Although the initial implementation would be centralized, the end goal is to create an Apache extension that could be adopted by those who would like to offer their own similar service. Once implemented, this type of content mirroring will enhance web-robustness in general, and create opportunities for wider application e.g. scholarship and archives.


	== Implementation Proposal ==		== Implementation Proposal ==

MirrorAsYouLink: Inception

2011-10-15T17:43:49Z

Inception

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
-<big>'''Mirror As You Link'''</big>
+<big>'''Mirror As You Link / Where's the Party (WTP)'''</big>
 == The Idea ==
-Here's an interesting idea...
+Where's the Party (WTP) is a project that seeks to help people preserve online content by making it easier (and more common) to mirror content.  The idea is not to have cluttered redundancy as was common with the early Internet, as the content of one website would be more or less reproduced on a number of other sites, but rather to have content reproduced in the background, waiting for a situation where the original website itself is no longer available.

WikiSysop: New page: '''Mirror As You Link''' == The Idea == Here's an interesting idea...

2011-10-04T21:30:32Z

New page: <big>'''Mirror As You Link'''</big> == The Idea == Here's an interesting idea...

New page

<big>'''Mirror As You Link'''</big>

== The Idea ==

Here's an interesting idea...

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:43, 13 November 2011
Line 1:		Line 1:
	<big>'''Mirror As You Link ~~/ Where's the Party~~ (~~WTP~~)'''</big>		<big>'''Mirror As You Link (MAYL)'''</big>

	== The Problem ==		== The Problem ==
Line 14:		Line 14:
	== The Idea ==		== The Idea ==

	~~Where's the Party~~ (~~WTP~~) is a project that seeks to help people preserve online content by making it easier (and more common) to mirror content. The idea is not to have cluttered redundancy as was common with the early Internet, as the content of one website would be more or less reproduced on a number of other sites, but rather to have content reproduced in the background, waiting for a situation where the original website itself is no longer available.		Mirror As You Link (MAYL) is a project that seeks to help people preserve online content by making it easier (and more common) to mirror content. The idea is not to have cluttered redundancy as was common with the early Internet, as the content of one website would be more or less reproduced on a number of other sites, but rather to have content reproduced in the background, waiting for a situation where the original website itself is no longer available.

	In practice, ~~WTP~~ will work like this: An independent reporter links to the website of a political activist from Iran, and uses ~~WTP~~ to ensure that if the activist's website goes down, the content that she linked to will still be available. While the activist's website is still up and available, the mirrored is not apparent or intrusive. Later, however, the activist's website goes down as a result of a DDOS attack. Without ~~WTP~~, the reporter would no longer be able to provide access to the activists content. However, with ~~WTP~~ implemented, when a reader clicks on the link to the activist's website and finds that it is down, the reader will automatically be redirected to the mirror of the website, rendering the DDOS attack ineffective in silencing the activist.		In practice, MAYL will work like this: An independent reporter links to the website of a political activist from Iran, and uses MAYL to ensure that if the activist's website goes down, the content that she linked to will still be available. While the activist's website is still up and available, the mirrored is not apparent or intrusive. Later, however, the activist's website goes down as a result of a DDOS attack. Without MAYL, the reporter would no longer be able to provide access to the activists content. However, with MAYL implemented, when a reader clicks on the link to the activist's website and finds that it is down, the reader will automatically be redirected to the mirror of the website, rendering the DDOS attack ineffective in silencing the activist.

	Such an implementation would provide a means for those running servers to preserve online content, but would not provide a means for the bulk of netizens to do so. As such, we also envision creating a tool, much like [http://tinyurl.com/ TinyURL] or [http://www.webcitation.org/ WebCite], that would allow users without websites of their own to create mirrors of content. This service could be marketed as an online source preservation tool. Although the initial implementation would be centralized, the end goal is to create an Apache extension that could be adopted by those who would like to offer their own similar service. Once implemented, this type of content mirroring will enhance web-robustness in general, and create opportunities for wider application e.g. scholarship and archives.		Such an implementation would provide a means for those running servers to preserve online content, but would not provide a means for the bulk of netizens to do so. As such, we also envision creating a tool, much like [http://tinyurl.com/ TinyURL] or [http://www.webcitation.org/ WebCite], that would allow users without websites of their own to create mirrors of content. This service could be marketed as an online source preservation tool. Although the initial implementation would be centralized, the end goal is to create an Apache extension that could be adopted by those who would like to offer their own similar service. Once implemented, this type of content mirroring will enhance web-robustness in general, and create opportunities for wider application e.g. scholarship and archives.
Line 24:		Line 24:
	'''STAGE 1: Apache Extension		'''STAGE 1: Apache Extension
	TECHNICAL:'''		TECHNICAL:'''
	A. There exists an open-source ~~WTP~~ Apache extension available on package managers, sourceforge, etc.		A. There exists an open-source MAYL Apache extension available on package managers, sourceforge, etc.
	B. The extension enables the following two backend calls for Web page authors:		B. The extension enables the following two backend calls for Web page authors:
	<SNAPSHOT ref=http... name="mysnapshot-9/23/11">: If unique(ref,name) does not exist, make a server-side copy of it and present a ~~WTP~~ link.		<SNAPSHOT ref=http... name="mysnapshot-9/23/11">: If unique(ref,name) does not exist, make a server-side copy of it and present a MAYL link.
	<BACKUP ref=... name=... every=24h>: As snapshot, but update the snapshot every 24h.		<BACKUP ref=... name=... every=24h>: As snapshot, but update the snapshot every 24h.
	Various other configuration options might exist.		Various other configuration options might exist.
	C. The server administrator (as opposed to Web page authors) can install server policy that overrides author-created ~~WTP~~ links, e.g.		C. The server administrator (as opposed to Web page authors) can install server policy that overrides author-created MAYL links, e.g.
	"Update backups no more than once every 48h."		"Update backups no more than once every 48h."
	"Use no more than 1MB for snapshots."		"Use no more than 1MB for snapshots."
Line 38:		Line 38:
	"Contact me@gmail.com if you have any questions."		"Contact me@gmail.com if you have any questions."
	etc.		etc.
	E. When a ~~WTP~~ link is followed, the server shows the target page in an iframe that says,		E. When a MAYL link is followed, the server shows the target page in an iframe that says,
	"A ~~WTP~~ snapshot exists of this page. Would you like to see it? Yes/Dismiss/About"		"A MAYL snapshot exists of this page. Would you like to see it? Yes/Dismiss/About"

	'''LEGAL/SOCIAL:'''		'''LEGAL/SOCIAL:'''
	Our hope is to encourage server adoption by separating administrator and author liability.		Our hope is to encourage server adoption by separating administrator and author liability.
	In particular, we want a server to be able to say in its terms of service, "You are responsible for all content mirrored by ~~WTP~~ links,"		In particular, we want a server to be able to say in its terms of service, "You are responsible for all content mirrored by MAYL links,"
	and achieve DMCA safe-harbor by complying with takedown requests on specific links.		and achieve DMCA safe-harbor by complying with takedown requests on specific links.
	This seems in no way different from content on the actual pages (e.g. pictures),		This seems in no way different from content on the actual pages (e.g. pictures),
Line 51:		Line 51:
	and that the contact info in mirrors.txt is a location to forward legal requests to (e.g. DMCA takedowns).		and that the contact info in mirrors.txt is a location to forward legal requests to (e.g. DMCA takedowns).

	We ~~would~~ pitch this to the Wikimedia Foundation as "Install this extension and you will have time-aware snapshot citations."		We could pitch this to the Wikimedia Foundation as "Install this extension and you will have time-aware snapshot citations."


	'''STAGE 2: Web Service'''		'''STAGE 2: Web Service'''
	'''TECHNICAL:'''		'''TECHNICAL:'''
	A. We provide a Web site almost identical to tinyurl. It has the ~~WTP~~ Apache extension.		A. We provide a Web site almost identical to tinyurl. It has the MAYL Apache extension.
	B. Users with an account can create ~~WTP~~ snapshot and backup "tinyurls" to use on their own pages.		B. Users with an account can create MAYL snapshot and backup "tinyurls" to use on their own pages.
	C. Optionally, like tinyurl we can provide browser extensions that plug into this service.		C. Optionally, like tinyurl we can provide browser extensions that plug into this service.

	'''LEGAL/SOCIAL:'''		'''LEGAL/SOCIAL:'''
	The purpose of this service is to encourage ~~WTP~~ adoption by authors who do not control their own servers.		The purpose of this service is to encourage MAYL adoption by authors who do not control their own servers.
	Our terms of service states that users are responsible for the copies they make.		Our terms of service states that users are responsible for the copies they make.
	We do not provide a content finding service: users are responsible for making others aware of their copies.		We do not provide a content finding service: users are responsible for making others aware of their copies.
Line 70:		Line 70:
	TECHNICAL:'''		TECHNICAL:'''
	A. A mirrors.txt file may optionally identify a bittorrent/DHT tracker.		A. A mirrors.txt file may optionally identify a bittorrent/DHT tracker.
	B. If so, then a ~~WTP~~-enabled server will join the torrent rather than taking snapshots.		B. If so, then a MAYL-enabled server will join the torrent rather than taking snapshots.
	C. When the shapshot is requested, the server provides the page distributed in the torrent.		C. When the shapshot is requested, the server provides the page distributed in the torrent.
	D. The torrent is cryptographically signed such that only the owner of the page can update.		D. The torrent is cryptographically signed such that only the owner of the page can update.