Difference between revisions of "Notes on the Research Works Act"

From Harvard Open Access Project
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 37: Line 37:
  
 
* '''AAP members who oppose the RWA''' (chronological by announcement date):
 
* '''AAP members who oppose the RWA''' (chronological by announcement date):
*# [http://mitpress.mit.edu MIT Press]. See the January 11, 2012, [https://plus.google.com/u/0/109377556796183035206/posts/CWBxzWCuwKx announcement] from Ellen Faran, Director of MIT Press.
+
*# [http://mitpress.mit.edu MIT Press]. See the [https://plus.google.com/u/0/109377556796183035206/posts/CWBxzWCuwKx announcement] from Ellen Faran, Director of MIT Press. January 11, 2012.
*# [http://www.ithaka.org ITHAKA].  See the January 12, 2012, [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/ithaka-becomes-second-aap-member-to.html announcement].
+
*# [http://www.ithaka.org ITHAKA].  See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/ithaka-becomes-second-aap-member-to.html announcement], January 12, 2012.
*# [http://www.clir.org/ Council on Library and Information Resources] (CLIR).  See the January 12, 2012, [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/ithaka-becomes-second-aap-member-to.html?showComment=1326456086032#c2896926308984064302 announcement].
+
*# [http://www.clir.org/ Council on Library and Information Resources] (CLIR).  See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/ithaka-becomes-second-aap-member-to.html?showComment=1326456086032#c2896926308984064302 announcement], January 12, 2012.
*# [http://www.psupress.org/ Penn State University Press]. See the January 12, 2012, [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/pennsylvania-state-university-press.html announcement] from Patrick Alexander, Director of the Penn State University Press.
+
*# [http://www.psupress.org/ Penn State University Press]. See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/pennsylvania-state-university-press.html announcement] from Patrick Alexander, Director of the Penn State University Press, January 12, 2012.
*# [http://www.rupress.org/ Rockefeller University Press]. See the January 13, 2012, [https://groups.google.com/a/arl.org/group/sparc-oaforum/browse_thread/thread/6d13954c261a61b9 announcement] from Mike Rossner, Executive Director of Rockefeller University Press.
+
*# [http://www.rupress.org/ Rockefeller University Press]. See the [https://groups.google.com/a/arl.org/group/sparc-oaforum/browse_thread/thread/6d13954c261a61b9 announcement] from Mike Rossner, Executive Director of Rockefeller University Press, January 13, 2012.
*# [http://www.ucpress.edu/ University of California Press].  See the January 13, 2012, [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/university-of-california-press-differs.html announcement] from Alison Mudditt, Director of the University of California Press.
+
*# [http://www.ucpress.edu/ University of California Press].  See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/01/university-of-california-press-differs.html announcement] from Alison Mudditt, Director of the University of California Press, January 13, 2012.
*# [http://npg.nature.com/ Nature Publishing Group] and [http://www.digital-science.com/ Digital Science].  See the January 18, 2012, joint [http://www.nature.com/press_releases/rwa-statement.html announcement] from Steven Inchcoombe, Managing Director for NPG, and Timo Hannay, Managing Director for Digital Science.  (Digital Science is a [http://www.digital-science.com/about/ sister company] of NPG.)  
+
*# [http://npg.nature.com/ Nature Publishing Group] and [http://www.digital-science.com/ Digital Science].  See the joint [http://www.nature.com/press_releases/rwa-statement.html announcement] from Steven Inchcoombe, Managing Director for NPG, and Timo Hannay, Managing Director for Digital Science, January 18, 2012.  (Digital Science is a [http://www.digital-science.com/about/ sister company] of NPG.)  
*# [http://www.aaas.org/ Association for the Advancement of Science] (AAAS).  See the January 18, 2012, [http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2012/0118rwa.shtml announcement] from Ginger Pinholster, Director of the AAAS Office of Public Programs, and Alan Leshner, AAAS Chief Executive Officer.
+
*# [http://www.aaas.org/ Association for the Advancement of Science] (AAAS).  See the [http://www.aaas.org/news/releases/2012/0118rwa.shtml announcement] from Ginger Pinholster, Director of the AAAS Office of Public Programs, and Alan Leshner, AAAS Chief Executive Officer, January 18, 2012.
*# [http://www.mla.org/ Modern Language Association]. See the January 25, 2012, [http://www.mla.org/ec_opp_rwa announcement] from Michael Bérubé, President of the MLA.
+
*# [http://www.mla.org/ Modern Language Association]. See the [http://www.mla.org/ec_opp_rwa announcement] from Michael Bérubé, President of the MLA, January 25, 2012.
 
*# [http://www.aip.org/ American Institute of Physics]. See the AIP's [http://www.aip.org/press_release/RWA_position_statement.html announcement] (undated but released on January 31, 2012).
 
*# [http://www.aip.org/ American Institute of Physics]. See the AIP's [http://www.aip.org/press_release/RWA_position_statement.html announcement] (undated but released on January 31, 2012).
 
*# [http://www.wiley.com John Wiley & Sons]. See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/02/john-wiley-sons-have-no-plans-to.html statement] Wiley allowed Richard Poynder to post to his blog, February 10, 2012.
 
*# [http://www.wiley.com John Wiley & Sons]. See the [http://poynder.blogspot.com/2012/02/john-wiley-sons-have-no-plans-to.html statement] Wiley allowed Richard Poynder to post to his blog, February 10, 2012.

Revision as of 09:08, 23 February 2012

The bill itself

  • The main section (Section 2) is brief: "No Federal agency may adopt, implement, maintain, continue, or otherwise engage in any policy, program, or other activity that -- (1) causes, permits, or authorizes network dissemination of any private-sector research work without the prior consent of the publisher of such work; or (2) requires that any actual or prospective author, or the employer of such an actual or prospective author, assent to network dissemination of a private-sector research work."

Sponsorship

  • According to MapLight (Money and Politics Light), Elsevier has given two campaign contributions to Issa and 12 to Maloney for the 2012 campaign cycle. Out of 31 contributions Elsevier has made to House members for this cycle, 14 or 45% have gone to Issa and Maloney.

Publisher opposition

  • This section tries to track the publishers who have publicly opposed the bill.
  • AAP members who apparently oppose the RWA, but whose positions require confirmation
    1. University of Chicago Press. In a January 17, 2012, comment on Richard Poynder's blog, Arno Bosse reports that the U of Chicago Press told him that it does not support RWA. But Bosse doesn't speak for the press and doesn't quote a statement from the press.
    2. Cambridge University Press. A week after CUP told Richard Poynder that "it is too early for us to make any public statements" on RWA, Poynder was allowed (January 17, 2012) to share this statement from Peter Davison, CUP's Director of Corporate Affairs: "Cambridge University Press has submitted testimony to the United States Office of Science and Technology in response to the Request for Information (2011-28623) on subjects related to HR 3699. Our testimony is not identical to the position adopted by the Association of American Publishers. In particular, we write: ‘We support all sustainable access models that ensure the permanence and integrity of the scholarly record... The Bill as proposed could undermine the underlying freedoms expected by and of scholarly authors....’ "
    3. American Anthropological Association. On February 3, 2012, the AAA Executive Committee issued a statement opposing "any Congressional legislation which, if it were enacted, imposes a blanket prohibition against open access publishing policies by all federal agencies." On the one hand, this description taken literally does not describe the RWA. On the other, this interpretation of the RWA is very common and might have been held by the AAA Executive Committee.

Other opposition

Limited to major statements.

  • Twenty-six higher-education, library, and public-interest organizations: American Association of University Professors, American Historical Association, American Library Association, Association of American Physicians and Surgeons, Californians Aware, Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington, Community Research, Cost of Government Center, Defending Dissent Foundation, Demand Progress, Doctor Patient Medical Association, Essential Information, Humanist Society of New Mexico, iSolon.org, Mine Safety and Health News, National Coalition Against Censorship, National Coalition for History, OMB Watch, OpenTheGovernment.org, Progressive Librarians Guild, Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, Rutherford Institute, Sage Information Services, Society of American Archivists, Society of Professional Journalists, Special Libraries Association, Tully Center for Free Speech at Syracuse University, Utah Foundation for Open Government, Washington Coalition for Open Government, and the William A. Wise Law Library at the University of Colorado Law School. See their February 9, 2012, joint open letter to Congress.
  • The eleven provosts of the universities in the Committee on Institutional Cooperation (CIC): University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Indiana University, University of Iowa, University of Michigan, Michigan State University, University of Minnesota, University of Nebraska at Lincoln, Ohio State University, Pennsylvania State University, Purdue University, and the University of Wisconsin at Madison. See their joint statement, February 23, 2012.

Action against the RWA

  • See the petition against the RWA at We The People, the White House petition site. Online since January 23, 2012. If the petition gathers 25k signatures, the Obama administration will review it and issue an official response.

Discussion